• Home   /  
  • Archive by category "1"

Cortez And Montezuma Thesis Statements

Hernán Cortés 1485–1547

(Variations on first name include Hernándo, Fernán, and Fernándo) Spanish conquistador and New World chronicler.

Cortés is chiefly known as the conqueror of the Aztec empire and the founder of colonial Mexico. His significance in American historiography has been largely informed by his correspondence, or, Cartas de relatión (1519–1526) that he wrote to the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V (King Charles I of Spain) recounting various stages of the Mexican conquest. As a firsthand account of one part of the conquest of the Americas, these letters are a valuable resource not only for historical data, but also for what they reveal of the conquistador mentality.

Biographical Information

Cortés was born in the Spanish town of Medellin in approximately 1484. His father, Martín Cortés de Monroy, was a minor aristocrat without titled lands who nonetheless provided his son with the opportunity, as part of the gentry, to participate in Spain's growing colonial enterprise. After studying law for two years at the University of Salamanca, Cortés abandoned his scholarly pursuits in 1504 and travelled to the Caribbean island of Hispaniola, where he worked as a notary. He accompanied Diego Velázquez in his conquest of Cuba in 1511 and served as his secretary for the next seven years. During this period he married Catalina Xuárez, who was related to Velázquez by marriage. In 1518, Velázquez put Cortés in charge of an expedition to explore the Mexican coast. Ignoring Velázquez's orders to confine his activities to exploration and trade, Cortés set out to conquer the powerful Aztec empire. After making an alliance with the Tlaxcalans, traditional enemies of the Aztecs, Cortés proceeded to the Aztec capital, Tenochtitlán, where he was received as an emissary of Charles V by the Aztec leader Montezuma II. Cortés took Montezuma prisoner and for some time was able to rule through him. During an Aztec uprising in 1520, however, Montezuma was slain, either by the Spanish or by his own people, and Cortés and his men were forced out of the city with heavy losses. After a protracted siege, during the course of which the city was virtually razed, Cortés finally defeated the Aztecs in 1521. The next year the emperor named him governor of Mexico, or

"new Spain." Following an abortive expedition into Honduras, Cortés was suspended from the office of governor in 1526. Two years later he returned to Spain to seek redress from the Emperor. Although the Emperor conferred on him the title of Marquis and confirmed his claim to the considerable wealth he had acquired in the New World, Cortés was not reappointed governor. He returned to Mexico that year, but never again exercised political power. In 1540 he retired to Spain, where he died in 1547.

Major Works

Cortés's letters to Charles V provide a detailed account of his activities in Mexico from 1519 to 1526. Compilations of these Cartas de relatión usually include five letters, although the first of these is actually a letter from the municipal council of Vera Cruz, the first city established by Cortés in Mexican territory, describing the foundation of the city and presenting the Spanish monarch with all the treasure (instead of the customary royal fifth) acquired thus far in the conquest. This letter is generally included in place of Cortés's own first letter, of which no copy exists. In fact, despite references to this first letter in Cortés's later correspondence, some scholars doubt its existence. The letter from the municipal council emphasizes Cortés's services to the crown and portrays Cortés's immediate superior, Governor Velázquez of Cuba, as a self-interested official who sought to restrict Cortés's activities to trade and exploration in order to enhance his own wealth and power at the expense of the Crown's interest in acquiring new territories. In the subsequent letters written by Cortés, the conquistador continued to describe and justify his actions while staking his claim to hold his authority directly from the king. The second letter describes events from the war against and alliance with the Tlaxcalans through the noche triste ("sad night") of July 10, 1520, during which Cortés lost over half his army during the flight from Tenochtitlán. The third letter records the siege and reconquest of the city, while the fourth letter describes Cortés's administration of the conquered territories. These four letters were published in Spain during Cortés's lifetime, helping to establish his reputation as one of the great conquistadors. His final letter, concerning his disastrous expedition to Honduras in 1526, reflects his experience of bureaucratic controls that greatly constricted his authority in New Spain, and differs markedly from the earlier letters in tone and content; it was not published until the nineteenth century.

Critical Reception

Though he is assured a position in history as the conqueror of Mexico, Cortés's reputation is a subject of continuing debate. Until the twentieth century, Cortés's letters fulfilled their apparent purpose of perpetuating their author's fame and glory. However, changing attitudes towards colonialism during the course of the twentieth century have brought a réévaluation of Cortés's historical role, with many historians emphasizing his ruthless methods and his destruction of a flourishing civilization. This historical re-visioning has been accompanied by a focus on the letters as literary artifacts rather than as objective descriptions of the conquest of Mexico. Jonathan Loesberg (1983), for instance, looks at various rhetorical strategies employed by Cortés in his letters to establish his right to make decisions independent of his immediate superior, the governor of Cuba. Anthony Pagden (1971) also discusses ways in which Cortés seeks in his letters to reinforce both his authority and his reputation. In a similar vein, Stephanie Merrim (1986) examines how Cortés, in constructing his persona as narrator and agent in his Letters, seeks to present himself as a model subject and military leader in the service of the emperor. Inga Clendinnen (1991), on the other hand, finds in Cortés's letters indications of cultural miscommunications that contributed to the vulnerability of the Aztecs in the face of the Spanish invasion.

Conquistador History: Cortés And Montezuma Essay

Hernán Cortés intended to bring back riches from America not conquer a people, but he and his conquistadors, who coincided with the return of the god Quetzalcóatl, were responsible for the death of the Aztec emperor, Montezuma.
From 1502 to 1520, during the height of their mighty empire, the Aztecs had before them their most famous ruler of all time. Born in 1466 and of noteworthy lineage, Montezuma II proved himself as a young warrior and politician and was inaugurated as the Aztec emperor in 1502 after his uncle, Emperor Axayacatl, died. His accession to rule saw him inherit a massive empire that stretched from what is now the modern day southern United States to Central America. This large are was difficult to control and revolts and civil wars were commonplace. Suppression of internal fighting through campaigns of ritualistic sacrifices, slaughtering of villagers and imposition of heavy tributes marked him as a vicious ruler. Despite this harshness, Montezuma brought reform to the Aztecs, replacing commoners in important positions with nobleman. Between 1504 and 1510, he engaged in several battles that served to unify the empire as the preeminent force in Mexico.
In 1510, Montezuma turned his attention to a series of revolts and revolutionary flare-ups in the Aztec territories. These battles only increased the size of the Aztec Empire. The Aztecs also continued their Flower Wars with the Tlaxcatlecans to provide human sacrifices to their god Huitzilopochtli. Around the same time, Montezuma’s oracles passed information that there were strangers in the midst. In fact, his astrologer priests foretold of the coming of Quetzalcóatl, a white bearded god who was believed to eventually reclaim their empire. Reputed claims of White Men on Aztec territory surfaced in 1517 and fueled the prophecy of Quetzalcóatl’s arrival. Montezuma feared the return of Quetzalcóatl and instituted a spy network to gain valuable information and insight on the activities of the invasive White Men. His fears would soon be realized, but with a far different outcome than he, or the Aztecs, ever expected.
Born in Medellín, Spain in 1485, Hernán (Hernando) Cortés was one of noble upbringings yet his quest for riches would change the course of his life. Before embarking on his trans-Atlantic journey there is a good chance that he spent some time studying at the University of Salamanca. Cortés’ eventual voyage to the Americas went a long way to help solidify Spain’s prominence in the new world.
By 1504, Cortés had sailed to the West Indies, and in 1511 he was enlisted with Diego Velázquez on a voyage to Cuba. During 1518, Cortés was appointed as the captain general for a new Spanish expedition to unearth the riches of the Americas. Hernán Cortés then set sail for America, despite a rescinded order from Diego Velázquez, Cortés’s former shipmate and current governor of Cuba.
In February 1519, Cortés disembarked from his journey in the Yucatan area of what is now...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

The Destruction of the Aztecs as a Result of Miscommunication and Lack of Cultural Understanding

6470 words - 26 pages The collision of the Spaniards and the Aztecs was a collision of two alien cultures that had evolved over thousands of years, each unknown to the other. Here we have two empires that see the world through two totally different perspectives. Miscommunication and lack of cultural understanding were major factors in the breakdown of diplomatic relations between the Aztecs and Spaniards. The Aztec perspective was based on prophecy and sign but the...

The Spanish Conquest Essay

1587 words - 6 pages Introduction: THE SPANISH CONQUEST of the Americas is an interesting story of exploration, wealth, greed, devastation and death. The Aztec civilization, which lived in what we know today as central and South America, began to come under threat from European explorers during the late 15th century. The Aztec civilization was one of the most spectacular in the world, and at its heart was the masterpiece of the Aztec capital, Tenochtitlan. However,...

Hernando Cortez

720 words - 3 pages Hernando Cortez was one of the bravest military leaders of all time. Born in Medellin, Spain, he was a Spanish Conquistador who conquered most of Central America. He explored to find riches and conquered by being observant of the natives. As a result, with a small army, he conquered the Aztec Empire. In 1519, Cortez explored the Yucatan coastline. Landing in Tabasco, Cortez captured the natives. These natives wore bright colored...

Hernando Cortes Conquered Mexico

860 words - 3 pages Hernando Cortes was one of the bravest military leaders of all time. Born in Medellin, Spain, he was a Spanish Conquistador who conquered most of Central America. He also gave Spain three-hundred years of control over Mexico. Cortes started exploring in the early 1500’s. He explored to find riches and conquered by being observant of the natives. With a small army, he conquered the Aztec Empire. Cortes went to the university in Salamanca, Spain....

Document Analysis: The Second Letter of Henan Cortés to Charles V

1628 words - 7 pages Document Analysis: The Second Letter of Henan Cortés to Charles VThe Second letters to Charles V were written by Hernan Cortés of Spain in 1520. The letters were sent to Charles V to justify Cortés actions of attacking the Aztec's against his superiors order. The letters that Cortés wrote details the lifestyle, and culture of the Aztec's and how worshipped pagan gods. This...

Age of Exploration and its effects on slave trade and America

664 words - 3 pages European influence in the Americas commenced in the late fifteenth century, whenChristopher Columbus set sail for the Indies.However, he discovered a "new world", theAmericas. This phenomenal breakthrough would forever change the complextion of the world.European prominence in the Americas can be viewed as a catastophe. These...

Hernando Cortez

1151 words - 5 pages Hernando Cortez was one of the bravest military leaders of all time. Born in Medellin, Spain, he was a Spanish Conquistador who conquered most of Central America. He also gave Spain three-hundred years of control over Mexico. Cortez started exploring in the early 1500’s. He explored to find riches and conquered by being observant of the natives. With a small army, he conquered the Aztec Empire. Cortez went to the university in Salamanca,...

Spanish vs Aztec weaponry

3674 words - 15 pages When the conquistadors were battling the Aztecs, weapons that were thousands of years apart were pitted against each other. The Spaniards had the best European steel available, as well as an early form of musket, while the Aztecs fought with weapons made from wood, rock, and copper.(Hassig, 1992) The machuahuitl, a razor sharp sword, the tematlatl, a sling, and the tlacochtli, an obsidian pointed spear, were all simplistic, but the Aztecs...

Terrorism and the Causes of Terrorist Attacks

2312 words - 9 pages   The continuing successful and attempted terrorist attacks in the USA and the endless wars and conflicts in which we are involved are caused by the very same reasons experienced in the expansion of Europe during the 15th and 16th centuries.  The economic, political, and cultural conditions present in each of these periods in history, although hundreds of years apart, are still very much alike.  The same desires for money, relations between...

Hernán Cortés

2045 words - 8 pages During the late 15th century, the Spanish Empire was preparing itself. It was rapidly becoming the pinnacle of exploration, conquest, and colonization. The future laid the path for many men to take part in this epic stage of expansion. Thus, the stage for Hernán Cortés Pizarro was set to leave his imprint and story of conquest in...

The Many Dimensions of the Mexica Indian Empire

1726 words - 7 pages The Mexica Empire was a grand civilization with many accomplishments and merits. Even Bernal Díaz would later lament the destruction of the capital of Tenochtitlan (Townsend 126). Conversely, the society was not entirely destroyed by the Spanish, as the preservation of native stories, traditions, and languages shows. The indigenous people were not only victims, but agents, in the Empire’s transition through the conquest. On one hand the Mexica...

One thought on “Cortez And Montezuma Thesis Statements

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *